After a grueling legal battle spanning nearly two decades, Nyla Kureshi and her husband have finally found justice. A Nairobi court has awarded them a landmark 157 million Kenyan shillings in damages from Aga Khan Health Service Kenya, following a botched surgery that irrevocably altered Nyla's life. The judgment, delivered on June 4, 2025, marks a significant victory for patient rights and underscores the severe consequences of medical negligence.
The harrowing ordeal began in September 2006 when Nyla Kureshi was admitted to Aga Khan Health Service Kenya for what was supposed to be a routine procedure to treat pelvic endometriosis. However, the course of events took a devastating turn when Dr. Rafi Parker, entrusted with her care, performed an unauthorized removal of her cervix during a procedure that was only consented for the removal of her uterus and ovary. This unauthorized act was deemed by the court as grossly negligent and a blatant violation of Nyla's fundamental patient rights.
The consequences of this botched surgery were catastrophic. Nyla Kureshi suffered life-altering injuries, leading to the loss of her employment and severely diminishing her earning capacity. The trauma extended beyond the physical realm, profoundly impacting the quality of life for both Nyla and her husband. The court recognized the significant loss of amenities and consortium they endured, acknowledging the deep emotional and relational toll of the negligence. Specifically, the removal of her cervix resulted in a loss of sexual enjoyment and the inability to satisfy her husband sexually, adding another layer of devastation to their lives.
In its ruling, the court meticulously itemized the damages awarded to the couple, totaling 157 million shillings:
7 million shillings: For special damages, covering the extensive medical treatment Nyla sought in Nairobi and South Africa to address the complications arising from the surgery.
30 million shillings: For the unauthorized and deeply damaging removal of her cervix, recognizing the profound and irreversible impact of this act.
40 million shillings: For the loss of consortium, compensating for the disruption and damage to the marital relationship.
20 million shillings: For the loss of amenities, acknowledging the diminished quality of life Nyla experienced due to her injuries.
10 million shillings: For the pain and suffering endured by Nyla as a result of the negligent procedure.
20 million shillings: For the loss of earning capacity, reflecting the significant financial impact of her injuries on her career.
30 million shillings: Awarded directly to Nyla's husband for the loss of society and services, recognizing the impact on their marital life.
While another medical practitioner involved in the case was cleared of wrongdoing, Aga Khan Health Service Kenya was held accountable for a shocking breach of its duty of care. The court found that the hospital was aware that Dr. Rafi Parker had been disbarred from medical practice in Uganda, a critical piece of information that should have prevented him from performing the surgery. Furthermore, the hospital's failure to provide essential diagnostic equipment hindered the timely detection of complications, further exacerbating the situation.
This landmark judgment sends a powerful message: medical negligence will not be tolerated, and hospitals will be held accountable for the actions of their staff and the standards of care they provide. The long and arduous journey of Nyla Kureshi and her husband serves as a testament to their resilience and unwavering pursuit of justice. Their victory not only provides them with much-needed compensation but also sets a precedent for patient rights in Kenya, ensuring that healthcare providers are held to the highest ethical and professional standards. This case is a stark reminder that behind every medical procedure is a human life, and the trust placed in healthcare professionals must be sacrosanct.
Read More On This Topic
Read More On This Topic
